On Islam, Division, and Unchanging Water
By Abu Batool Abdullah
May/Jun 26
The Mississippi River originates at Lake Itasca inside Itasca State Park in northern Minnesota. From this modest lake — small, quiet, almost humble — the river begins its long journey southward to the Gulf of Mexico, approximately 2,340 miles. From north to south, the river flows through or forms borders of the states of Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Illinois, Missouri, Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, Mississippi, and Louisiana.
After joining the Missouri River near St. Louis, its volume increases dramatically. After joining the Ohio River at Cairo, Illinois, it becomes wider and more powerful. But the name remains “the Mississippi River” throughout. The water’s chemical composition also remains the same: H₂O.
As the river flows, it gathers sediments (mud, sand, and minerals) and absorbs nutrients. It receives runoff from farms and cities, changes temperature, speed, and depth. At its source in Minnesota, it is clearer, colder, and narrower. By the time it reaches Louisiana, it is brown with sediment – warm, vast, and slow-moving
The ecosystems differ in northern forests, in Midwestern agricultural regions, in Southern wetlands, and delta marshes. By the time the river reaches the delta in Louisiana, it carries millions of tons of sediment annually, agricultural nutrients, and industrial and urban pollutants. The river begins as a quiet trickle in Minnesota and becomes a continental artery. Yet its chemical identity remains constant. Its form, force, color, and social meaning transform — but its essence remains water. Its character deepens. Its burdens increase. Its influence expands. But H₂O remains H₂O.
As does Islam.
The Flow of the Faith
The beginning of Islam is as clear as Northern Water. Revelation descended in a cave outside Mecca. A single Prophet (salla Allahu ‘alayhi wa sallam), a single recitation, and a single community bound not by tribe but by faith. The Quran flows pure, unadorned. But the early believers are few. There is no sect, no school, no theological debate — only tawḥīd, prayer, fasting, struggle, and mercy. Like Lake Itasca, the source is modest yet decisive. The river at its origin is not yet burdened with silt. The community at its origin is not yet burdened with faction.
Every river gathers tributaries. Every community gathers history. After the Prophet’s death, the current meets its first great convergence: the question of leadership. Who guides the flow? Who holds authority? What is succession? From this confluence emerge Sunni and Shia currents — not as separate rivers, but as powerful streams interpreting the same source differently. The water does not change its molecular structure. But the river’s path begins to branch. Political contest becomes theological reflection. Loyalty becomes doctrine. Memory becomes identity. Sediment enters the current. The water is still H₂O. The Quran is still the Quran. The Shahada remains unchanged. But the river is no longer alone in its channel.
As the Mississippi flows southward, it gathers the Missouri, the Ohio, and countless smaller tributaries. Each adds volume, color, and force. Likewise, Islam gathers schools of jurisprudence — Ḥanafī, Mālikī, Shāfiʿī, and Ḥanbalī. It gathers Ashʿarī and Māturīdī theology, Sufi mysticism, and philosophical kalām. It gathers local customs, languages, and empires. The current grows wider.
One may look at the water in Minnesota and compare it to the muddy breadth in Louisiana and wonder: Is this the same river? The answer is yes — and no. Yes, in essence. No, in appearance. The river now carries sediment from farms, minerals from mountains, and debris from cities. It reflects the skies of ten states. It bends to the terrain. It adapts to obstacles. It deepens where pressure demands.
Islam, too, carries civilizations — Persian poetry, Andalusian philosophy, Ottoman law, Indian spirituality, African resilience. The Quran remains. The prayer remains. The fasting month remains. But expression diversifies. Some currents emphasize law. Some emphasize love. Some emphasize rationality. Some emphasize literal fidelity. Water remains water. The river becomes civilization.
Disturbance, Not Dissolution
No river escapes contamination. Industrial runoff darkens the Mississippi near cities. Agricultural nutrients flow into it. Sediment thickens its color. Yet, even as it carries impurities, the molecular identity of water remains H₂O.
Islam’s history, too, contains conflict — civil wars, sectarian polemics, political exploitation, colonial disruption. The names of sects multiply. Accusations harden. Identity becomes defensive. At times, observers look upon the surface — turbulent, brown, divided — and declare that the river itself has changed. But the essential recitation remains unchanged in its Arabic cadence. The daily prayers continue to align foreheads to earth. The call to prayer still echoes across continents. The divisions are banks, not essence. The disputes are sediment, not substance.
At its southern end, the Mississippi disperses into a delta — many channels spreading into the Gulf. From above, it appears fragmented, fractured into fingers of water and marsh. Yet these distributaries are not separate rivers. They are extensions of one flow, shaped by geography, gravity, and time. In the modern world, Islam appears similarly dispersed — Sunni, Shia, Ibāḍī; reformist, traditionalist, modernist; juridical, mystical, and philosophical. Movements rise and fall. Nations claim guardianship. Scholars debate authenticity.
From above, it looks like fragmentation. From within, the shahada remains singular. The Quran recited in Jakarta is the same that is recited in Cairo. The river has widened. It has carried burdens. It has absorbed history. It has bent around rocks of power and empire. But its molecular identity has not altered.
The Uninterrupted Course
There is a temptation — especially among critics — to judge a river by its sediment. To declare that because the water appears brown, its nature has changed. But sediment does not alter the chemical structure of water. It alters clarity, not essence. Similarly, sectarian division alters political expression, not theological foundation.
Islam’s core remains Tawḥīd — the unity of God; Prophethood — the finality of Muhammad; Revelation — the Quran preserved; Worship — the five pillars. What changes is interpretation, emphasis, governance, culture — the banks along which the water flows. The river deepens with tributaries. The Ummah deepens with history.
The Mississippi does not deny its tributaries. It does not reject the Missouri for being muddy or the Ohio for altering its volume. It absorbs them and continues. Islam’s vitality has often rested in similar absorption — accommodating diversity while guarding core creed. Division becomes dangerous only when tributaries forget their source. This happens when sect becomes greater than scripture, when identity becomes louder than revelation, and when sediment claims to be water. Yet the remedy is not to drain the river. It is to remember its origin.
Stand at Lake Itasca. Cup your hands in its clarity. Stand at the delta in Louisiana. Watch the immense, brown expanse enter the sea. Though unrecognizable in form, it is the same water.
Islam began in the desert with a single recitation. It now flows across continents, languages, and centuries. It carries jurisprudence, philosophy, mysticism, empire, reform, protest, renewal. It has known conflict and convergence. But the Quran remains recited in the same consonants. The prayer still turns toward the same qiblah. The call “Allāhu akbar” still proclaims the same transcendence. The river changes in expression. And yet the water remains water. And so too, beneath sect and school, beneath polemic and power, beneath history’s sediment, the essential current remains — tawḥīd flowing, uninterrupted, from source to sea.
Abu Batool Abdullah is a freelance writer.
Want more like this? Subscribe to the Islamic Horizons magazine and support authentic journalism by Muslims for Muslims.