A Reflection on Racial Injustice in the American Judicial System
By Imam Saffet Catovic
Jan/Feb 25
On September 24, 2024, the State of Missouri committed an irreversible and grievous act: it executed Marcellus Williams, a black man who maintained his innocence until his last breath.
Imam Marcellus “Khalifah” Williams’ unjust execution starkly highlights the systemic racism and deep-seated biases that plague the American judicial system – issues rooted in a painful history of discrimination against African Americans. While the United States has made strides toward justice, this tragedy serves as a poignant reminder of the distance we still must cover in dismantling the legacy of racial inequality that persists in our society.
Despite compelling evidence suggesting his innocence, Williams – wrongfully convicted of a 1989 rape and murder – was denied clemency, even as the prosecuting attorney and the victim’s family appealed for the execution to be halted. This heartbreaking outcome underscores a system that often prioritizes punishment over justice, silencing the voices that seek truth, healing and accountability.
Disproportionate Incarceration Rates
Williams’ plight is not an isolated incident; it reflects a broader pattern of racial injustice in the United States. According to the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), African Americans are incarcerated at more than five times the rate of white Americans. In 2021, black men made up approximately 33% of the male prison population, despite comprising only 6% of the U.S. population. This stark disparity reveals a system that disproportionately targets black individuals.
A study by the Prison Policy Initiative found that black Americans are more likely to be sentenced to prison than white Americans for similar offenses. For instance, black individuals receive sentences that are, on average, 19.1% longer than those given to their white counterparts for the same crimes. This disparity is further exacerbated by racial profiling, which leads to higher arrest rates and, consequently, higher incarceration rates among black communities.
Judicial Miscarriages and the Innocence Project
The Innocence Project highlights another layer of injustice: wrongful convictions. According to their data, over 70% of the 375 DNA exonerations in the U.S. involved people of color. Racial bias in jury selection and prosecutorial decisions significantly contributes to these miscarriages of justice. For example, a study by the Equal Justice Initiative found that Black defendants are more likely to be wrongfully convicted than white defendants, with the risk of wrongful conviction being 2.5 times higher for Black individuals.
In many cases, these wrongful convictions arise from faulty witness identifications, coerced confessions, and/or prosecutorial misconduct. The Innocence Project reports that mistaken eyewitness identification contributes to nearly 75% of wrongful convictions. Furthermore, the prevalence of implicit bias among jurors can result in unfair judgments against black defendants, leading to longer sentences and, in extreme cases, the death penalty as in the case of Imam Marcellus Williams.
In Williams’ case, the St. Louis County prosecutor’s office filed a 63-page motion to vacate his 2001 conviction for the killing of a journalist in her home. The prosecutor noted new DNA evidence that exonerated Williams along with growing doubts about the credibility of key witnesses heaped upon violations of Williams’ constitutional rights during his trial. Among these were ineffective counsel provided to Williams and racially discriminatory jury selection all of which prompted the reviewing attorney to request the circuit court to “correct this manifest injustice”.
The Death Penalty and Racial Disparities
Williams’s execution exemplifies the racial inequities present in the judicial system. According to the Death Penalty Information Center, black defendants are more likely to receive the death penalty than white defendants. In fact, a 2019 study found that Black individuals made up 41% of those on death row, despite representing only 13% of the U.S. population. Moreover, cases involving white victims are more likely to result in a death sentence for black defendants, highlighting a racial bias that permeates capital punishment.
Imam Williams’ execution is a tragic example of how this bias can manifest. His trial, along with mountains of statistical evidence cataloguing judicial discrimination in the U.S., indicates a deeply flawed process that often prioritizes racial bias over justice. His unjust death at the hands of the State of Missouri raises important questions about the integrity of a system that allows such stark disparities to continue.
The Role of Systemic Racism
The injustices faced by individuals like Williams stem from a complex web of systemic racism, which manifests through structural and institutional biases. Racism is not merely an individual prejudice but a pervasive system that impacts policies, practices, and social norms. As Ruth King explains in Mindful of Race: Transforming Racism from the Inside Out, racism is a societal “heart disease” that can only be addressed through awareness and education.
Culturally enforced norms rooted in the past of wrongful enslavement of Africans continue to fuel structural and institutional racism today. For instance, racial profiling and discriminatory policing practices contribute to the over-policing of black communities. A 2020 American Civil Liberties Union report states that black individuals are three times more likely to be stopped by police than white individuals despite similar rates of drug use and other criminal activity across racial groups.
Another example of these systemic and systematic racial injustices is that of Imam Jamil Al-Amin (formerly H. Rap Brown), a prominent Muslim American leader and civil rights activist. He gained recognition in the 1960s as a member of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) and later as chairman of the Black Panther Party. In 2002, Imam Jamil was convicted of murdering a sheriff’s deputy in Atlanta, Georgia., a crime he has consistently denied committing.
His case further underscores systemic racism and failures within the criminal justice system. Many observers argue that his conviction was influenced by racial bias, including the context of his activism and the prejudiced perceptions of black leaders at the time. According to a report from the Center for Constitutional Rights, Imam Jamil’s trial was also marked by significant irregularities, including inadequate legal representation and questionable witness testimonies.
Moreover, the prosecution’s reliance on racial stereotypes and the media’s portrayal of him as a violent radical contributed to a biased narrative that overshadowed the evidence. The racial dynamics at play in his case exemplify how the justice system can disproportionately affect African Americans, particularly those with a history of activism. This highlights a broader pattern of injustice, where race and social standing significantly influence legal outcomes.
Building Solidarity in the Fight for Justice
As an organization dedicated to supporting African American Muslims, Muslim Alliance in North America (MANA) recognizes that the Muslim community is intertwined with this struggle. They must come together to address these injustices and advocate for reform within the judicial system. The fight for justice is not solely the responsibility of marginalized communities; it requires solidarity from all who seek equity and fairness.
In the wake of tragedies like Williams’ execution, we are reminded of the ongoing work needed to combat systemic racism, judicial inequities, and social injustices. All people must continue to raise awareness, educate themselves and others, and stand in solidarity with those affected by these injustices.
Williams’ case serves as a painful reminder of the systemic injustices that persist in the American judicial system. As one reflects on his life and the injustices he faced, one must remain resolute in their vision for an America where justice, equality, and compassion reign. The statistics surrounding racial disparities in incarceration, wrongful convictions, and the death penalty underscore the urgent need for reform.
Believers are commanded in the Quran, “O you who believe, be upright for God, and be bearers of witness with justice!” (5:8), They are further commented, “O you who have believed, be persistently standing firm in justice, witnesses for Allah, even if it be against yourselves or parents and relatives. Whether one is rich or poor, Allah is more worthy of both” (4:135).
In the spirit of justice, let all people unite against these injustices, hold accountable those who perpetuate them, and work toward a judicial system that serves all individuals fairly. Together, all people can strive for an America that embodies the principles of fairness, compassion, and the unwavering protection of innocent lives.
Imam Saffet Catovic is director of UN Operations for Justice For All and board member of MANA.